Pin It  

Weekly questionSince I’m giving the scale, oh I mean platform, away I thought it was the perfect week to ask part of Jodi’s question

Do you weigh yourself everyday?

This question fascinates me as I’m been on both sides of the discussion. I do believe in weighing everyday but I don’t actually do it anymore. I truly think it depends on where you are in your own personal journey. To read my history with the scale click here for my Scale Habits post.

In short, I haven’t weighed myself in a few weeks! Lately, I’m really trying to find my way without the scale. Ask me after the holidays if I succeeded! :~P

Right now I’m more interested in if YOU weigh yourself every day and why you do or don’t.


Tagged with:
 

72 Responses to Do You Weigh Everyday?

  1. Hi Roni,

    Great topic, as it is one that stirs up many opinions! I personally swing both ways as well. Sometimes I do weigh every day, sometimes I don’t. When I am traveling, and/or really busy I don’t. But when I am in the mood to track my trends, I do. I used to do it as an obsessive thing, but these days, it’s more of an interest in knowing what happens to my body when I eat different foods, do different things, etc.

    I have never felt like weighing one time a week is accurate, as our weight tends to fluctuate so much. For example, I could eat something with lots of sodium the night before weighing, and then step on the scale the next morning for my weekly weigh-in, and be “up” a pound. If I didn’t know about trends, then, in the past, this could have really thrown my whole/day off.

    If I track, then I see the trend going in the downward direction consistently over time if I am trying to lose fat, or the trend sticks right around one number, if I am maintaining. I know that a lot of people think of the scale as a bad thing, but I see it as merely a tool. As long as you use it as tool of measurement to make sure that you are consistent toward reaching your goal, then I don’t see anything wrong with weighing everyday (at the same time of day, keeping the variables consistent as well). It just goes back to one’s relationship with their body and getting to that comfortable place where a number doesn’t make or break the day.

    So that was my long winded response. :-) Take care.

    Sheila
    http://www.livewell360.com

  2. Jill says:

    I weigh myself every other day usually, and then one “official” weigh in a week. It’s funny how I don’t really care too much what the scale is throughout the week, but the night before the “official” weigh in I get a little nervous. I also tend to not weigh myself after a bad day (food wise) because that can be discouraging and result in overeating for many days as opposed to one.

  3. suzane says:

    I weigh myself daily just to keep myself accountable and yes it’s fascinating somedays just how your body works!!

  4. Janice says:

    I do. It keeps me on track.

  5. No question: every day. Does this work for everybody? ‘Course not. The rationale, of course, is that day to day weight fluctuations are generally meaningless and don’t always paint the big picture. Worse, a small uptick might send you off on an unplanned Cheez-It bender.

    That’s rarely, if ever, been a problem for me. Not to sound snooty, but I’m a bit above that. Granted, I’m not saying that a mysterious 3-pound overnight gain has never bothered me. But it’s not a reason to fall off the wagon.

    For me, I need the data. (And anyone who’s seen my book or blog has seen what I do with eighteen years of near-daily weigh-ins.) I couldn’t weigh in at all last week. It was really hard! I needs my Platform!

  6. Debbie says:

    Nope, not every day…only the days I feel like I’ve done well or I feel “skinny” ….(now that’s a laugh). I’m like what you are doing right now…avoid the scale if you don’t want to see what is there. Get on the scale if you think there is good news. Take today for instance. It is my weigh in day at Weight Watchers…Tues. mornings, 9:00am sharp. I KNOW it ain’t good news, so I have not even gone into the room where the scales live. I don’t even ask the weigher-in lady what it was after I weigh. I don’t even look at my book after the meeting is over. I wait until next week or later in this week when I feel like I’ve made some progress (i.e. left all that dressing behind until next year).

    Thanks for the great posts. Also, THANK YOU for the POM coupon! I’ve tried it and probably won’t buy it again….cost vs taste.

  7. crazylady says:

    I do. I just can’t resist… sometime it’s twice a day – morning and evening. I do however make a very conscious effort to treat it just as a number and not make too big a deal out of it. It’s a way of monitoring my progress otherwise how would I know genuine how I’m doing. I find it actually helps when I feel bloated or whatever and then see a gain on the scales because I know there’s a reason for it and it will pass. Long term I do want to get away from the scales but not until I have things under control.

  8. Patty says:

    When I was actively trying to lose weight (lost 20# last winter) I did weigh myself every day, sometimes more than once. I truly was scale obsessed. But I would only record in my journal a weekly weigh in, and I also took monthly measurements. I really think the measurements were so helpful because they provided a visual for me, inches I could SEE. I’d strongly reccommend measurements also because sometimes you’ll see changes in inches more so than pounds.

    Now that I’m maintaining I weigh much less often, maybe weekly, and I tend to go more by the fit of my clothes.

  9. Christine says:

    For awhile I was weighing everyday–I wanted to take the focus off the scale when I went to WW meetings–and it worked! Now I weigh every couple of days and definitely the morning of my WW weigh in. For me, weighing frequently has taken away the fear of the number, and given me an understanding of how much my weight fluctuates!

  10. Robin says:

    This is such a good question. I am at the very beginning of my weight loss journey, but have been working at it for quite some time :( It has been such a slow process for me.

    I tell myself often that I’m not going to weigh myself every day. What happens is that I think that I have had a good couple of days but when I step on the scale, I am either up a little bit or I haven’t gone down at all. This leads me to think, “Why bother” and then I eat more than I should. I think that if I could just think positively and think that I am losing weight without stepping on the scale, I might actually lose more weight. I hope that makes sense to someone but me :)

    The thing that stops me is my fear of what the scale will say after some time away from it. What if I go a couple of weeks, or even a week, and I think that I have done well and the number is up? That would be extremely discouraging for me.

    I’ll be reading what other people have to say about this!! Thanks for posting this!!

  11. Jennscookin says:

    I usually weigh in everyday, but only log the days I lose or on Fridays if it stays the same. My problem is that when I stop weighing in on a regular basis, I get more frustrated. By the time I finally dare to step on the scale I find that I am up several pounds and then get even more frustrated with myself and give up. So, I am really trying to stay committed to weekly weigh-ins. It works for me, but I think that each person should find what works best for them personally. If I remind myself that it is only the main Friday weigh-in that counts for the week, I do much better.
    The daily weigh-ins just help me stay accountable.
    Jenn

  12. Beth says:

    I started going back to WW meetings and do one “official” weigh every week there but I do hop on my scale everyday (and sometimes more than once a day to see how different foods and drinks affect me). I like to see how my official weigh is probably going to go…up or down….and be prepared for it. Obviously something is going right….I’m 0.2 from goal now!!! This week is my week, I can feel it!! But yes, I do weigh myself daily unless I’m out of town and don’t have my scale.

  13. Amber says:

    I do when I’m on track because it keeps me going. When I’ve had a few off-plan, giving into old habits days, I find myself just letting it go – more out of fear than anything else.

    I do find that weighing every day is generally encouraging. I’m only 7 months into this journey, and I am so afraid that one morning I’m going to wake up and the scale will say 209 again. For me, it encouragement that I can actually do it and eating snacks or something extra cheesy and gooey in moderation won’t kill the progress I’ve made. Plus, it’s nice to start the day seeing numbers I haven’t seen since I first got married almost 9 years ago. ;)

  14. Brandi says:

    I try and weight myself on the same day at the same time every week. Sometimes I go 2 weeks or 3 weeks depending on how I’m feeling. This is mostly because scales and numbers got me into some trouble awhile back and my life started revolving around that stupid little number. Now I know that I only do it to record progress, because I do need the feedback. But I don’t let myself do it if I know its going to affect my entire day. I feel more free because I know the number doesn’t affect who I am, it only reflects my body’s reaction to the things I do with it. I think its very important to have a way to record progress, but sometimes its more important to listen to your body and feel the differences when you eat right and exercise.

  15. Krista says:

    Great contest!
    I used to be a scale-a-holic! I would get on that damn thing 3-4 times a day! No joke. What an obsession. We moved to a new house last year and there is no bathroom on the main floor. That means the scale is no longer in my face when ever I walk down the hall. Now I only get on Wednesday mornings. I’m happy to have kicked that bad hbit! One at a time, tight?!
    Anyways, check out my post! http://www.kristaskravings.blogspot.com
    Thanks, Roni!!

  16. Lori says:

    I’m sad to say, I weigh everyday. It must be an obsession! I try not to let the number sway my decisions through out the day and I try and be rational about “why” the scale has gone up or down. It amazes me how much body weight can change in one day. I still don’t always understand the gain/loss as it can be drastic. I try and account for salt intake and fiber, but my irrational mind doesn’t always want to accept it. Maybe once I figure that out, I can stop the weighing. I know it’s just a number and it should be about how I feel, but that would be too rational. LOL
    Thanks again for all you do. Your efforts truly DO encourage and change peoples lives.
    I also want to thank you for the Pom Coupons. I haven’t used them yet, but I will! :-)

  17. Tara from Portland says:

    I weigh every day if I am at home. I used to only do once a week and found that my results are better now that i weigh daily. I think this holds me more accountable. After doing it for a month or so I know where my fluctuations come from and they dont send me spiraling to get a few cookies or anything. I have lost more now that i weigh daily opposed to once a week.

  18. KT says:

    I struggle with this one. Sometimes I weigh myself everyday, but that can get frustrating and I find that I get too hung up on it. I try to only weigh myself the day of my WW weigh-in so I know what to expect, but I’ll admit that sometimes I cheat. I guess I’m just coming to grips with the fact that I only have so much control over that number and as long as I’m doing the things I need to be, it shouldn’t matter.

  19. LeeAnn says:

    Wow, it is great to hear what other people have to say about this. I normally weigh myself every thursday, but there are times when I NEED to weigh myself. After big meals or lack of exercising, I weigh myself to see the damage. This seems to keep me on track.

  20. Tanya says:

    I’ve never weighed myself everyday – I think how much can you really lose in 1 day?! And accounting for the fact that it’s not true weightloss. Of course, this is just for me. I think everyone has to do their own thing. The most I’ve ever weighed myself is once per week. To be honest, when I gain weight I don’t want to know and I don’t weigh. When I’m losing I can never do it fast enough and I don’t want to know cuz the scale never moves down enough!

  21. Azad says:

    I used to religiously but not so much anymore. Now it’s once or twice a week. I think it’s definitely helpful. I would much rather weigh myself every day then do the alternative – throw it in the closet which and let it collect dust which is what I used to do when I would pretend that I was not gaining weight.

  22. Shannon F. says:

    I do weigh every day but right now I am definitely driven by the numbers. I don’t worry about it if I don’t such as I didn’t weigh all weekend but did when we got home. For me it’s seeing how my body reacts throughout the week.

  23. Anna says:

    i weigh weekly at WW and usually once in between on my home scale. oh, and i hop on the home scale right before going to WW so i know the “difference” between the two. i like my home scale better; its 4lbs lower than the WW one. LOL

  24. Melissa M. says:

    I admit it. I weigh every day. Like others, I feel like it helps keep me accountable to myself. I will say it’s been interesting to see how certain foods definitely affect the scale. For example, if I eat a canned soup, I know the scale will be up the next day even if I stay within my Points target. So from that I’ve learned not to eat canned soup, popcorn, etc. within a couple of days of my WW weigh in. ;-)

  25. Tiffany says:

    Hi Roni – I have been meaning to read your blog forever (I came over from Newlywed Girl). I weigh myself everyday with an offical weigh in every Monday morning. I have to see the number so there is no way I could deal with the scale you are advertising!

  26. Shannon says:

    I weigh every couple days because I have no patience but I weigh “officially” for tracking purposes once per week on same day.

    Totally off subject, I keep seeing these posts saying thanks for POM coupons – is there a link to POM coupons?? I like POM!

  27. Rachel says:

    Looks like I’m in the minority here, I weigh once a week- every Monday morning. I truly believe that’s one of the reasons I’ve been successful. I used to weigh every day and I was constantly focused on the wrong thing- the number-and I let it affect my eating. I decided I didn’t want to be put through that emotional rollercoaster anymore and have stuck with once a week the whole time I’ve been on weight watchers. Now I focus on just eating healthy and I love to be surprised and have no idea how much I’ve lost at my weigh in. It’s kinda fun that way! Plus, if most people are only supposed to be losing 2 pounds a week, how much is it going to change in one day anyway? I don’t use it as a way to “keep on track” throughout the week because having control over your eating and eating healthy is more important than the actual number to me. Obviously if I wasn’t losing weight then I would know my eating isn’t where it should be, so I just use the scale as guide to know I’m losing!

  28. I’ve weighed myself everyday since I got my scale last Tuesday. It’s not because omg i’m sooo obsessed with weighing myself everyday, but because I have a new scale and weeee it’s fun and exciting to have something new!

  29. Christie says:

    I do not weigh every day. For the longest, I didn’t have a scale. Then my mother-in-law cleaned out her garage and found 2 scales so she gave us one. It’s not digital and it’s pretty unreliable so I don’t really use it. We have at work in health services so if I feel like I need to know, I will go there when I’m at work. I would say that it’s been at least a month since I checked. I have never been one who weighs every day. I would rather weigh every week if I am trying to lose and maybe once a month if I am trying to maintain.

  30. Paige says:

    I weigh myself every day, but I count it as “official” every other day. For the official weigh-in, I write the number down in my running log. Weighing on a daily basis keeps me focused, accountable, and motivated.

  31. Rachel says:

    I do weigh myself every day and I write the number in my food journal but it is more out of curiosity for how the body’s weight fluctuates every day than an obcessive thing. It has allowed me to see trends in my weight and really has taught me a lot about my own body.

  32. Bonnie says:

    At the beginning and middle of my 68 week weight loss journey, I never got on my home scale. I only weighed in at my weekly WW meeting. Towards the end though, I have usually weighed about once or twice a week on my home scale…I’m not even sure why, but perhaps because weight loss is so slow towards the end so I just wanted to know…or perhaps try to rush it a bit. This is my first week of maintenance and I have not weighed at home, but I did weigh at Curves last night and weighed the same as my goal weight that I weighed at WW last Wednesday night. And that’s after Thanksgiving and a 3 point increase in my daily points that my WW Leader gave me. So I feel good about that.

  33. Amy says:

    Hey~
    yes I weigh myself everyday. i don’t let it shake me too much- it just gives me an idea of how i’m maintaining. as long as it’s within a certain range, I’m happy.

  34. Nicole says:

    I weigh myself at home most days, then officially at my WW meeting on Saturday mornings.
    If I am lower than the day before that motivates me to “keep it up.” And if I am higher it motivates me to be honest with myself about being on plan.

  35. Currently I don’t, because it ruins my day.

    When I am eating right and staying on track, then I will because it helps to hold me accountable.

  36. Kris says:

    THIS IS SWEET!!!!!!

  37. Becca says:

    Def no. Chances are, my weight wouldn’t have gone done noticeably in the past 24 hours, so there really is no need to let the weigh bring me down everyday.

  38. Annette says:

    for awhile, I only weighed once a week…………then I started going overboard and weighing in several times a day. I am now back to trying to just weigh once a week but I have peeked after a day of not so good eating to see what damage a day did.

    I could very easily become obsessed. Hubby said he would hide it and bring it out only on my weigh in day if I ever feel I need the help ;)

  39. Pubsgal says:

    I weigh daily: one time, first thing in the morning. But I only log it once a week. I think it’s working for me because I’ve found myself adjusting if I don’t lose or post a gain…or if the number starts trending up over the week. I think it’s also helpful that I’m tracking lots of other health-related things (foods, exercise, blood glucose levels), so I’m not so focused only on the scale number. (I also think I’m doing this daily as sort of a counter-reaction to not stepping on it all during my gaining years.)

  40. Dori says:

    I DITTO SHEILA~

    Great topic, as it is one that stirs up many opinions! I personally swing both ways as well. Sometimes I do weigh every day, sometimes I don’t. When I am traveling, and/or really busy I don’t. But when I am in the mood to track my trends, I do. I used to do it as an obsessive thing, but these days, it’s more of an interest in knowing what happens to my body when I eat different foods, do different things, etc.

    I have never felt like weighing one time a week is accurate, as our weight tends to fluctuate so much. For example, I could eat something with lots of sodium the night before weighing, and then step on the scale the next morning for my weekly weigh-in, and be “up” a pound. If I didn’t know about trends, then, in the past, this could have really thrown my whole/day off.

    If I track, then I see the trend going in the downward direction consistently over time if I am trying to lose fat, or the trend sticks right around one number, if I am maintaining. I know that a lot of people think of the scale as a bad thing, but I see it as merely a tool. As long as you use it as tool of measurement to make sure that you are consistent toward reaching your goal, then I don’t see anything wrong with weighing everyday (at the same time of day, keeping the variables consistent as well). It just goes back to one’s relationship with their body and getting to that comfortable place where a number doesn’t make or break the day.

    So that was my long winded response. :-) Take care.

    Sheila

  41. Brandie says:

    I weigh daily first thing in the morning. Then do one official weigh in at Weight Watchers. It works for me to see the scale daily and realize it is just a number. I like to know how food affects my body. I try to keep a log of what I eat and how full it keeps me.

  42. Lourdes says:

    While I gained I only got weighed during doctor visits. So now, I weigh every day with one day of the week being the official day. I may not be losing but I want my eyes WIDE OPEN to the process now.

  43. Lisa says:

    Almost every day – first thing in the morning. Basically to watch what’s happening. I only officially log it once a week. But it helps to see if I’ve been doing okay or not during the week.

  44. Arlene says:

    Well, I waffle. Sometimes I weigh myself every day (usually when I’ve done really well OP the day before and want to see the results of that hard work on the scale). But I use the weekly WW WI, on Monday, as my official weight.

    Once I hit my goal, I plan to weigh daily because I once weighed 169 … and started avoiding the scale when I ate “badly.” The longer I avoided the scale because I didn’t want to know just how badly I was doing, the more weight I regained. I put 70 pounds back on while I was avoiding the scale …

    So this time, I’ll be weighing daily at first to maintain. I’ll probably taper off to 2 or 3 times a week eventually.

  45. i used to weigh myself every day, then one day i forgot and just decided, eh i’ll just start weighing every week. i think both ways are good. but for me weighing every week is good because i think it shows more overall progress. if i weigh every day, i get all freaked out if the scale doesn’t drop every day.

  46. Biz says:

    I stopped weighing myself every day in September – now only once a month. I lost 10 pounds in September, 5 pounds in October, and 0 pounds in November. But I didn’t work out nearly as much as I should have – but I consider maintaining a success! Hope to lose 5 by January 1st then the last 25 to 30 by summer. Fingers crossed! I just need to give up my wine!

  47. I weigh myself every morning and also sometimes at night. It does keep me on track and I also get to see how certain foods affect my body (ie: foods with more salt).

  48. Giyen says:

    My MD has advised me to weigh myself every day. She says that she read a study that discussed habits of people who managed long-term weight loss, here is what I remember:

    (1) Weighing yourself daily helps people to immediately intercept when their weight fluctuates outside a normal range.

    (2) Keep a food journal.

    (3) Join a weight loss support group.

    (4) Exercise.

  49. emi says:

    I weigh daily, but I take the # with a grain of salt. If I’m 132 one day, and 135 the next, I don’t freak out – I obviously didn’t overeat by 10,5000 calories the day before and gain 3 pounds of fat. However, if I go 132/133/134/133/134/134/134/135/135 or something, I am actually gaining weight & I try to cut back a little.

    Ideally, I think I wouldn’t ever weigh myself & I’d just go by clothing fit, but I’m not ready to do that yet.

  50. melissa says:

    When I am in active weight loss mode, YES, every day. I’ve gone years without weighing, as well. I KNOW when I’ve gained weight–I don’t need a scale. I was pretty low (for me, upper 120s) about a month ago but am definitely about 5 lbs up but I am not going to step on a scale. Right now (holidays, birthday) I know it would depress me instead of motivate me. That’s the question I really ask myself before I weigh…..”How is the number going to change how I feel?” I don’t want to feel bad (or worse). I will definitely weigh if I feel light on a particular day or if I am restarting “loss” mode…and always on January 1st just because!

    Also, my scale is not easily accessible. I don’t want my teenage girls on it all the time-all 3 have healthy weight attitudes and I don’t want to mess that up!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

BlogToLose

A Community of Weight Loss Bloggers. We are here to support, cheer on, pick up and reach our goals together! Join Us!